Emergency Management Blogs

Emergency Management Blog - Eric Holdeman: Disaster Zone
Disaster Zone

by Eric Holdeman: Emergency management in the blogosphere

Subscribe via RSS | About this Blog | Contact Eric Holdeman | Blog Roll

4 Tenets of Collaborative Decision Making
July 28, 2010
Bookmark and Share

Subscribe to Disaster Zone

Get Eric Holdeman posts delivered via

Emergency Management's Weekly Email
Disaster Zone RSS feed
Eric_Holdeman on Twitter


Sarah Michaels, Professor, University of Nebraska sent me a PDF of an article she co-wrote on Water-Related Decision Making. Since I can't post a PDF, I'm extrapolating a few key points and adding my own two cents for you here. Tenants

  1. There is a high cost of Interactions--Meaning that when you bring diverse groups together that all get to comment on and contribute to the decision making process it can get "messy." There will be likely diverging opinions based on constituencies and their values.
  2. People weigh their own experiences most heavily--People's own experiences trump all other forms of knowledge. So scientific evidence even when it is overwhelming may not be convincing. Scientists may be considered the "outsiders" who don't understand.
  3. Nothing happen quickly, and then something does--Amen here brother! The process drags on with little progress and then there is a "motivating" event and everyone wants to be included and have a say.
  4. Values, not science, arbitrates what happens--Again, science is not the determining factor, but the values, emotions and social structures come into play when we make decisions. Our goal needs to be incorporate the value based knowledge with that of scientific information.
All of the above makes you NOT WANT TO collaborate! But, in our modern society we need this type of interaction to make decisions that stick and lead to trust. Speed of decision making will slow, but in the end the process will help to make for a stronger community of people.
Top

Comments
Add a Comment


Science informs but does not decided! Attribution unknow but agree on this statement.
From William R. Cumming July 29

Latest Emergency Management News

Environmental Tectonics Corp.
Simulation-Based Training Provides Cost-Effectiveness, Flexibility

A virtual replica of New York City provides its Office of Emergency Management with a unique way to test its command element.
Leaking North Dakota Oil Well Temporarily Plugged

The well had leaked 2,200 barrels of water and 246 barrels of oil before being stopped.
Your Survey Submission is Successful!

Thank you very much for your survey participation. The winner of the BlackBerry® Bold™ 9650 smartphone drawing will be contacted upon close of our survey in approximately 3-4 weeks.

Latest Blog Posts RSS

Emergency Management Blog - Rick Wimberly & Lorin Bristow Alerting and Warning Emergency Management a Pawn in FM Chip Debate
Sep 10 There's quite a broohaha underway over whether chips for receiving FM broadcasts should be added…
Emergency Management Blog - Eric Holdeman: Disaster Zone Thad Allen on Lessons Learned
Sep 09 Thad Allen is now the preeminent federal responder to disasters of a national significance. I…
Emergency Management Blog - Eric Holdeman: Disaster Zone FREE: FEMA Tabletop Exercises
Sep 09 Everybody likes free! The below was shared with me by Diane Newman, my buddy from…

4 Ways to Get EM

Subscribe to Emergency Management MagazineFollow Emergency Management on TwitterSubscribe to Emergency Management HeadlinesSubscribe to Emergency Management Newsletters


Blog Archives



Weekly Newsletter Subscription

SUBSCRIBE TO EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT

Get 6 issues of EM's print magazine.
Subscribe Back Issues