Emergency Management Blogs

Managing Crisis

by Lucien G. Canton: Melding theory and practice

| Contact Lucien G. Canton

Does Separation of Church and State Prohibit Disaster Relief?
February 19, 2013
Bookmark and Share

Emergency Management Degrees

Visit our education pages to learn more about higher education opportunities in emergency management:

Emergency Management Degrees
Homeland Security Degrees
Emergency Management Certificates


Latest Blog Posts RSS

Emergency Management Blog - Eric Holdeman: Disaster Zone Water Disaster: FEMA Reimbursement
Apr 20 Take note that there are eligible costs that can be reimbursed.…
Emergency Management Blog - Eric Holdeman: Disaster Zone How Politics Buries Science
Apr 20 This example is for landslides, but the damage goes much further.…
Alerting Failure Draws Fire in Portland
Apr 17 The City says a failed alert this week was the fault of the alerting vendor. The vendor says it was the city's fault.…

One of the major historical trends in disaster relief has been the continued expansion of the services provided by the Federal government to disaster victims. From the first relief bills in 1790 that relieved the victims of the excise tax on goods destroyed by fire and flood, Federal disaster relief has changed from relief to specific individuals to assistance to a class of victims and from minor economic relief to major entitlement programs. According to Michele Landis-Dauber, author of The Sympathetic State, this expansion greatly influenced the New Deal policies of Franklin Roosevelt and led to the creation of the American Welfare State. We may well be seeing another major shift occurring.

In a recent vote the House of Representatives approved a bill that would allow the use of Federal money to rebuild places of worship damaged by the storm commonly known as Superstorm Sandy. This is a major departure from previous policies based on the Constitutionally-mandated separation of church and state.

The issue is complicated. On the one hand, places of worship are more than just places of religious observance. They are often a center of community life and may be used for multiple purposes. For example, the church that my family attends frequently reconfigures its liturgical space for community events such as dances, fund raisers and, most recently, an art show. In San Francisco, places of worship are an integral part of our winter shelter program, opening their space to house the homeless who would otherwise be at risk from severe weather. In times of disaster, many places of worship serve the community as shelters, feeding sites, or points of distribution.

This disaster role is recognized by FEMA and under certain conditions Federal reimbursements are available for social services performed by places of worship . As a business, places of worships can potentially qualify for Small Business Administration Loans. The issue here, however, is whether or not tax dollars should be used to rebuild places of worship on the theory that they are "pillars of the community" that should be treated the same as other non-profits such as zoos, libraries, theaters, etc. The argument against providing relief funding to places of worship is, of course, that such a use of taxpayer money would violate the Constitutional separation of church and state.

Should the Senate approve the bill in the coming weeks, there will be an immediate challenge from the American Civil Liberties Union and others, something that FEMA's attorneys are well aware of and have been attempting to avoid. If this is the case, it may be years before we have a final resolution and it will be a long, costly, and divisive conflict.



Add Your Comment

You are solely responsible for the content of your comments. We reserve the right to remove comments that are considered profane, vulgar, obscene, factually inaccurate, off-topic or a personal attack. Comments are limited to 2,000 characters.

Latest Emergency Management News

Moulage Provides Realism for ShakeOut Disaster Drill

The morbid makeup ensures that emergency responders have realistic-looking victims for disaster preparation drills.
Police officer working on a laptop
FirstNet Explained

FirstNet, the proposed nationwide broadband public safety network, is big, expensive and complicated. Here are a few basic things you need to know.
FirstNet Testbeds (Interactive Map)

FirstNet began negotiations with eight testbed jurisdictions, and the projects that did reach agreements should help shape the FirstNet network.

4 Ways to Get EM

Subscribe to Emergency Management MagazineFollow Emergency Management on TwitterSubscribe to Emergency Management HeadlinesSubscribe to Emergency Management Newsletters

Featured Papers

Blog Archives